Similar names do not mean the same winter capability
An all-season label usually describes everyday use in moderate weather. All-weather models commonly add the three-peak mountain snowflake qualification for snow traction while remaining intended for year-round use. Always check the exact tire rather than relying on the marketing category.
M+S is not the snowflake marking
A mud-and-snow marking is not the same qualification as the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol. Neither a tread that looks aggressive nor the name of the brand tells you the complete winter capability.
Choose your seasonal plan first
If you already run winter tires, a suitable all-season set may cover the other months. If you want one set, compare all-weather options while considering the winter driving you cannot avoid. For frequent demanding winter travel, include dedicated winter tires in the comparison.
Then compare the actual fitment
Match the full size, load index and required specification before comparing price, comfort and warranty. Different models from the same brand can fall into different seasonal categories. Ask about the particular tire you intend to buy.